Now that he is deeply involved with Adam and Tyler, Lucas can't help questioning if things are too good to be true. On the surface, he seems to have it all: a place in the pirate show, an exciting sex life with the two hottest men on the island, and a home in paradise. But he's still unsure of his place in his lovers' lives, torn between wanting to become serious with them and afraid he's being used as a tool to strengthen the other men's relationship. Believing that all of this is temporary, Lucas begins keeping secrets, and in the process he raises the stakes for all three of them and leads them to a make it or break it moment that will determine their future together.