Preacher's daughter, Janie Worthy, has spent years looking out for her father and siblings after the death of her mother. But as she watches her niece get married, Janie decides it's time to get a life of her own. However, her plan stalls out before it can even begin...literally. On the way to her first date, her car decides to quit, leaving Janie stranded on the side of the road. A stranger on a motorcycle becomes her savior. Caleb Montgomery is gorgeous and sexy, and the short time they spend together on the side of the road might be the most romantic interlude Janie can remember. Of course, it's all just a fantasy and soon Caleb is riding off into the night, never to be seen again. Until he shows up again where she least expects him...right in her hometown of Shellwater Key. When Caleb decides to stay in town for Christmas, Janie can't help but wonder if she is the reason. Except that would be crazy. People don't fall in love in one night...Right? As the holiday spirit kicks into high gear, Janie must find the courage to move beyond past guilt to embrace the future and open the best Christmas present she could ever find.