Tyler Gamble has been searching for his true love for years. He's been searching for the girl who makes his lips tingle when he kisses her, like the way his lips felt when he kissed Natalie Hogan back in high school. There'd been a few girls over the years, but none of them were right. They didn't make his pulse race, they didn't make his heart pound, but most of all, they didn't make his lips tingle. He's starting to think he'll never find the girl for him, until Natalie came back into his life after ten long years and a stolen kiss on the sidewalk changes everything. The only trouble is, to Natalie Hogan, Tyler is a player. He's the one who humiliated her and stole her teenage years. Could he win her trust again and make her see it's not a game, that this time he's playing for keeps, or is it too big a gamble for Natalie to take?