Can she forgive him for what he can't forget?
The last year has been a whirlwind of trials and triumphs for the Tanner family. With injuries, near foreclosures, and a family tragedy behind them, Jason Tanner, the oldest of the Tanner children is facing his own struggle after his longtime girlfriend, Ellie Lambert, overhears the secret he'd planned to tell her himself.
Now, in addition to trying to keep his family's dairy farm sustainable during a hard economic season, Jason is dealing with the heartbreak of Ellie's decision to end an almost 10-year relationship. In an effort to bury his feelings, he throws himself into his work on the farm and into volunteering with Spencer Valley's small volunteer fire company, where tragedy strikes the foundation of his faith during an already vulnerable time. Ellie has her own challenges to face as she tries to navigate a time of life where her expectations have been turned upside down and shaken out. As she copes with the decision to walk away from her relationship with the man she saw as her best friend, her flighty, less responsible younger sister shows up to further complicate an already complicated situation.