Kid Rock
may have styled his first live album,
Live Trucker
, after
Bob Seger
's classic
Live Bullet
, paying homage to the artwork right down to the typeface and also choosing to record in his hometown of Detroit, but if
caught
Seger
on the rise,
catches
Kid
on his decline. This isn't a hard-driving, sweaty
rock & roll
record; this is a Vegas revue, all glam and glitz, with its heart in showbiz. Of course,
has always had his tongue planted firmly in his cheek when he went about his self-mythologizing, particularly on his still potent and funny 1998 breakthrough,
Devil Without a Cause
, but on this live effort recorded largely in August 2004, his joking has turned into inadvertent self-parody. This wasn't the case on his eponymous 2003 effort, which may not have set the charts on fire, but it did capture him in good form, where his rough and rowdy ways still seemed roguishly charming. Here, it's possible to hear the toll that all the partying has taken on him: he sounds hoarse and winded, and when he trades lines with his keyboardist, it seems as if it's because he doesn't have the energy to finish the song, not because it makes for a better show. And while
the Twisted Brown Trucker Band
sound tight, they also sound too slick, never really giving this white trash
the grit that it needs. Of course, the album isn't helped by its ridiculously front-loaded sequencing, where
"Bawitadaba,"
"Cowboy,"
and
"Devil Without a Cause"
follow back to back in the first four tracks, and his next biggest hit,
"Picture"
(here performed with
Gretchen Wilson
, not
Sheryl Crow
), also appears in the first half of the record; with the exception of
"Only God Knows Why,"
the second half consists largely of new material, or lesser-known hits. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine