Leah is still grieving the death of her mother when her father decides to move the family to Stoney Brook, the small Amish community where he grew up. Leah misses her Englischer friends and all she has known growing up in a modern world, but soon come to accept her new home until she learns of her dad's budding romance and to top that off, she discovers her dad and others in the Amish community are keeping a tightly held secret about why her dad left Stoney Brook as a young man. Leah is confused and hurt by all the secrecy and decides to leave Stoney Brook to return to her previous hometown in Ohio. Tobias is hurt when he learns Leah has left home. After he talks to her on the telephone, he sets out to find Leah and bring her home. Will Tobias' love be enough to bring Leah home, or will she allow her dad's secret past to separate her from the man who loves her.