Is the past ever really past?
Can you truly ever trust anyone?
These are the questions Sheriff Cammie Farnsworth must face when she is suddenly confronted with a past she thought she'd long ago left behind. As the first female elected sheriff of Clarke County, Maine, Cammie has finally found peace in her life. However, that peace is shattered when hockey legend Eli Kelley suddenly returns to Twin Ponds. He and Cammie were once involved, and when he left to pursue a sports career, he left with a secret that almost destroyed her. When he is found murdered and Cammie is forced to make an arrest, the finger of guilt from the townspeople turns to her. With pressure mounting, Cammie must prove not only that she is innocent, but that the one person she doesn't want to believe is guilty may very well be a murderer.