That in the years after the release of this album
Marvin Gaye
became one of the greatest and most influential singers in the fields of
soul
and
R&B
is hardly a matter for discussion. What kind of impression the listening public might have picked up from
Soulful Moods
, his debut recording project, is another question, as it is certainly an uncharacteristic collection. It starts off with a whole run of standard numbers from the great era of American songwriting before tossing in a couple of trivial numbers from the developing
Motown
stable, including a
Berry Gordy
number that compares most unfavorably with the
Irving Berlin
,
Cole Porter
Rodgers & Hart
numbers that surround it. Fans of saloon singing may be curious to know how well
Gaye
fares in this difficult genre, and for the most part these are fine performances considering the versatile range of his voice and the depth of feeling he brought to most of his performances. No, this is not
with a fully developed style, and it is hardly the innovative legend of
Let's Get It On
or
What's Going On
but there is nothing he could have been embarrassed about here. The studio musicians come up with nice arrangements of the material, sometimes even with hints of the punch they would bring to his later, chart-topping material. ~ Eugene Chadbourne