Grace Church's life is a perfect mess. Her career is in the toilet, her love life is non-existent, and her beloved grandfather, the reason she became a cop in the first place, has just been murdered. So she is going home, to Mystic Lake, Pennsylvania. But home is far from a typical small town. It's the base of her mother's worldwide psychic empire, and the home of the former love of Grace's life. Sam MacMillan is also back in Mystic Lake and none too happy that Grace, his first love, is home. But the passion between them is hard to deny and soon is burning hotter than ever before. Grace digs into her grandfather's killing and the investigation that he was leading before he died. It becomes more than obvious that the two are connected. And that a serial killer has been working in the area for more than a decade. She must make peace with her past to find true love, catch a killer and keep her hometown from coming apart at the seams.